The Storm And The Rocking Horse Winner

Read the full essay 537 words
The Storm and The Rocking Horse Winner

Pia Adams

As a general rule, children love fairy tales. We grow up being read Grimm's or watching Disney remakes of classics. Parents love telling children fairy tales not only because they have an opportunity to spend time with their sons and daughters, but also because fairy tales, like fables, always contain a lesson or moral within them. Although both Kate Chopin's "The Storm," and D.H. Lawrence's "The Rocking Horse Winner" have some of the qualities of a child's fairy tale, only one of the stories has a moral tone, while the other has a very amoral one.

The beginning of "The Rocking Horse Winner" gives the reader a sense of fantasy. It starts off with "There was a woman who was beautiful, who started with all the advantages, yet she had no luck." Already the reader has a sense of timelessness, of an extraordinary, illusory reality. Lawrence continues on with this feeling when the narrator tells us of this beautiful woman and her feelings towards her children. "Only she herself knew that at the center of her heart was a hard little place that could not feel love, no, not for anybody." The narrator goes on to tell us the tale of a woman, unable to love her own children, who is obsessed with money. The house the family lived in was always filled with a whisper, "There must be more money!" This whisper is what leads to Paul becoming obsessed with money and luck like his mother. The dream-like tone that fills the story continues with the idea of the rocking horse helping Paul to find the winners of the races. In the end Paul dies, searching for the winner of the Derby through the night on his rocking horse. The moral of this story is a warning against being obsessed with money and luck, for the pursuit of these two things may kill you in the end.

"The Storm" begins with a much darker tone. It is set during a furious thunderstorm, a scene that foretells of dangerous happenings within the story. The passion of this storm is mirrored by the passion within Calixta and Alcee. While Calixta's child and husband are out in the storm, Calixta is having sex with a married man who she had previously been involved with. Instead of worrying about her family, she enjoys an extremely passionate interlude with another man. When the storm subsides, Alcee leaves her and her family comes home. It is obvious that this time with Alcee has affected Calixta because when her family returns Bobinot notes that she is acting differently. Unfortunately, this fairy tale has a mixed ending. Calixta and Alcee are never found out. There will be no punishment for their betrayal. The story ends with the line, "So the storm passed, and everyone was happy." This tale seems to tell us that betrayal of vows makes everyone happy. It is an amoral and even immoral message.

Both "The Storm" and "The Rocking-Horse Winner" are literarily sophisticated stories, yet they have some of the qualities of a child's fairy tale. They each contain very different lessons, one moral and the other amoral.

Related Topics

Literature The Storm Fiction The Rocking-Horse Winner Fairy tale Imagination Rocking horse The Rocking Horse Winner rocking horse winner kate chopin winner of the derby being obsessed with money moral tone d h lawrence timelessness remakes fairy tales sons and daughters beautiful woman fables narrator grimm fairy tale thunderstorm whisper feelings passion fantasy

More Free Essays Like This

1984 Review
A Changist View
A Dolls House And Tess Of The DUrbervilles
A Dolls House And Tess Of The DUrbevilles
A Historical and Modern Look at Child Abuse in the United States and N
A Separate Peace - Symbolism
A Whole New World
Abortion: Life Or Death - Who Chooses
abstract on Twelve Angry Men
Academic Achievement
Achilles Anophtheis (Achilles Revisited)
Aids Conspricay - Is AIDS Biological Warfare?
Albert Einstein
Alexander The Great
Alice In Wonderland
American history
American Romanticism in Edgar Allan Poes Ligeia
An American Tragedy And The Futility Of The American Dream
An Observation Of The Aeneid, Book II
Analysis Of Early Civilizations Through Literature
Analysis On Beowulf
Analyzing MacBeth According To The 7 Habits Of Highly Effective Teens
Ancient Greek Drama
Ancient Near East
Andrew Carnegie
Animal Farm
Animal Farm
Animal Farm And A Tale Of Two Cities: Social Criticism
Animal Farm As Animal Satire
Antigone: Gender Issues
Approaches and methods
Aristotle On Tragedy
Art, Literature And Society From 1955-1970
Barn Burning: Abner Snopes Character Analysis
Beowulf: Heroism
Bill Clintons Life
Blanche the Monarch Butterfly in a Streetcar Named Desire
Book review
Bury My Heart At Wounded Knee
Canon- means a closed list of writings that are c
Capacity-Related Innovations Resulting From
Capital Punishment
Carl Gustav Jung
Carlos Bulosan
Celtic Lifestyle
Champ D? Avoine
Charles Dickens
Charles Et Secondat, Baron De La Brede Et De Montesquieu
Chinese Footbinding
Compare & Contrast 3 Essays
Comparing And Contrasting Anglo-Saxon, Medieval, And Renaissance Perio
Comparing and Contrasting: Montressor and General Zaroff
Comparison Of Franklin & Douglass
Comparison Of Judaism And Christianity
Computer Education
couch potaoes
Cultural Analysis On Death And The Afterlife
Culture Of India
Culture Of India
Curriculum project
Death and the kings horsemen
Deciphering Jeremy Geddess A Perfect Vacuum
Development and Lifelong Learning for Infants
Doe Season: Andys Epiphany
Don Juan As Byron Introspective
Don Quixote
Don Quixote: The Misadventures Of A Lunatic
Early American Literature
Early Influences On Huckleberry Finn
Earnest Hemingways Books
Earnest Hemingways Works
Edgar Allan Poe
Education Of Gifted Children
Efficient Market Theory: A Contradiction Of Terms
Emily Dickinsons Poetry
Emporer Hadrian Of Rome
Environmental Conflicts In Literature
Epic Of Gilgamesh
Erik Padilla
Exile And Pain In Three Elegiac Poems
Exposing Children To Profanity
Fahim Patwary
Fahrenheit 451
Fahrenheit 451 And Brave New World
Field Of Dreams
Figurative Language
Flawed characters are always more memorable tha
French Literature In The Age Of Reason