Read the full essay 790 words


In Linda Pastan's poem "Ethics," the speaker recounts a moral dilemma that her teacher would ask every fall, which has been haunting her for a long time. The question was "if there were a fire in a museum / which would you save, a Rembrandt painting / or an old woman who hadn't many / years left anyhow?" and the speaker tells us through the theme that ethics and moral values can be only learned from the reflection which comes through experience and maturity. In this poem, imagery, diction, and figures of speech contribute to the development of the theme.

The speaker in the poem uses images to help to support the theme. For example the statement that "sometimes the woman borrowed my grandmother's face" displays the inability of the children to relate the dilemma to themselves, something that the speaker has learned later on with time and experience. In this poem, the speaker is an old woman, and she places a high emphasis on the burden of years from which she speaks by saying "old woman, / or nearly so, myself." "I know now that woman / and painting and season are almost one / and all beyond saving by children." clearly states that the poem is not written for the amusement of children but somebody that has reached the speaker's age, thus supporting the idea of the theme that children cannot help or understand her or anybody of her age. In addition, when the speakers describes the kids in the classroom as "restless on hard chairs" and "caring little for picture or old age" we can picture them in our minds sitting, ready to leave the class as soon as possible, unwilling and unable to understand the ethics dilemma or what the speaker is feeling.

The choice of words of the author also contributes to the development of the theme. For example, the use of words like "drafty," "half-heartedly," and "half-imagined" give the reader the idea of how faintly the dilemma was perceived and understood by the children, thus adding to the idea that the children cannot understand the burden the speaker has upon herself. In addition, referring to a Rembrandt as just a "picture" and to the woman as "old age," we can see that these two symbols, which are very important to the speaker and to the poem, are considered trivial by the children, thus contributing to the concept that the children cannot feel what the speaker is feeling. To add to the idea of old age of the woman, and to define the point of view more clearly, the speaker uses "old woman" a number of times.

The speaker uses the metaphors "The colors / within this frame are darker than autumn, / darker even than winter" and "the browns of earth, / though earth's most radiant elements burn / through the canvas." to give us the impression that the painting is not just a simple drawing, but it is something alive, something connected to the earth which is worth saving, thus putting it at the same level of the old woman, and thus making the dilemma more balanced. In addition, the idea of a color "burning through the canvas" puts more emphasis on the painting being something supernatural, thus increasing its status in the poem to be as high as (and maybe even higher than) the old woman. Symbolism is also used at the end of the poem, when the speaker describes the color of the painting as "dark than autumn, / darker even than winter" which adds to the idea that the painting is something that represents old age and death but that is also something natural, like a season. In addition, by saying that "I now know that woman / and painting and season are almost one / and all beyond saving by children" the speaker implies that both the painting and the woman represent something old, wise, and decadent, and are something that ethics say we cannot and should not easily give up, but children are not able to understand that, therefore they cannot save them.

In conclusion, this poem is not just about a lesson of ethics learned in school by a student. Instead, this

Related Topics

Social philosophy Axiology Ethics Philosophy of life Metaphor Rembrandt linda pastan moral dilemma figures of speech choice of words diction moral values old woman rembrandt poem maturity grandmother ethics reflection imagery chairs painting long time speakers images

More Free Essays Like This

1. Explain the Development of the global marketin
A Midsummer Night?s Essay
A Testament Of Hope - Martin Luther King
Adolf Hitler
All Kinds Of Love
American Labor Movement: Development Of Unions
An American Tragedy And The Futility Of The American Dream
An Observation Of The Aeneid, Book II
Ancient Greek Drama
Animal Farm And A Tale Of Two Cities: Social Criticism
Animal Farm As Animal Satire
Approaches and methods
Are books better than computers for learning
Aristotle biography
Aristotles Model of Responsibility
Art through the ages
Arthur Kornberg
Book review
Brazil: National Context
Candide: A Satire On The Enlightenment
Capital Punishment
Capital Punishment
Capitalism: Ayn Rand/ Maltese Falcon
Carl Gustav Jung
Celtic Lifestyle
Comparison Of Martin Luther King, Jr And Malcom X
Confucianism And Taoism
Criminological Research Paper
Determinism In Native Son
Dominican Basseball
Early Childhood ages 3-5
Effects of Gangsta Rap
Eighteenth Century Philosophers: A Comparison
Essence of Philosophy
Form And Malignant Form
Free-will And Determinism: Conflict And Choice
Freedom In The United States
Freedom In The United States
French Literature In The Age Of Reason
Gandhi & Churchillpresents the parallel live
God Thesis
hinduism and christianity
Historical Analysis Of The Painted Bird
History Of Physics
Howards End: Book Review
Immortality And Mortality In The Economic Sciences
Innovative school management strategies
Internet: A Medium Or A Message?
Invisible Man - Identity
Jane Eyre: Sexism
Jerline Ridges
Joseph Conrads 1899 novel is primarily narrated b
Karl Marx
Karl Marx
Karl Marx
Leda Atomica
Lewis Classroom Curriculum
Lord Of The Flies
Major events that caused change
Martin Luther King Jr And Malcolm X
Millenium Bug
Modernist and post modernism1
Morality Is Culturally Relative
Mrs dalloway
Multiculturalism In Canada
Narrative Techniques of Virginia Woolf and James Joyce
Native Son: Characters
No Exit And Its Existentialist Themes
Notes On Theories Of Mass Communications
On Empathy
Overview of Economics
Plato On Justice And Injustice
Political Parties And Their Roles In China And Canada
Political Philosophy Of Thomas Hobbes And Rene Descartes
Pre-School Curriculum
Primary Function of Human Resource Management
Private School Vouchers
Reasons Teen Disrespect Is On The Rise
Sayyid Qutb
Social Work 401OL-5 Social Welfare Policy Fall 201
Societys Restraint To Social Reform
Sociological Issues
Speech on Generalized Anxiety Disorder
Steps Towards The Russian Revolution
Student D eclaration
The 1960s
The Cons of Globalization, an Essay Against Global
The Cultural Narcissist
The Devil Has His Christs
The Enlightenment
The Fall Of Communism In Russia/Soviet Union
The Fourth Law Of Robotics